Yes, it would be nice if they were, but they are not. Many "Ratings" for equipment, not just in the aquarium hobby, are 50% random conditions, 50%whatever marketing wants the results to be. Battery manufacturers will test their batteries at different current draws to get the capacity they want, computer power supply manufacturers will slap different rating stickers on the same power supplies depending on what the buyer wants, speed controllers for electric motors will be tested at different amounts of airflow for cooling and then the safety factor increased or decreased for whatever rating they want...