Well, it would burn less electricity yeah...Well, or about the same, depends if it's magnetic or electronic ballast. And tend to penetrate a bit better so if you have a deep tank it would be better. I think bulb replacement would be cheaper also than replacing 4 t5 tubes. The only place it wouldn't be better would be if you spread the 4 tubes out over a larger area they'll cover a large area with dimmer light vs the mh which would be concentrated on a relatively small area(Depending on reflectors, etc)