As i said, its primarily for protecting a $1,000 return pump for roughly $250 more (or of course alot less if it were diy). Who knows where a leak may occur - especially if I went away for a weekend,.. or even a day,... or possibly even 5 minutes? The main tank and refugium are "protected" by overflows. The sump is protected by nothing, nor is the plumbing between each tank and nor is extended power failure or failure of a dosing pump for topup due to evaporation. Its a risk im not willing to take as warranty is void if the pump fails from running dry. Question is about these particular units, not whether I need one or not.