Jump to content

How secure would this stand be?


Squirt

Recommended Posts

Hi

I'm in the process of building my own stand. The dimensions will be 1700 x 550w x 500h. It will be supporting about 500kgs due to the tank not being completely full.

The top and bottom frames

d1be92f0.jpg

Everything in the above photo will be made from 100x50.

This is the front view/frame

120b44af.jpg

I'm not sure how clear it is, but the shaded area is the side on view of the top and bottom frame.

The vertical supports will be 100x100. Ie the back left, back middle, back right, front left, front middle and front right vertical ones are 100x100

I plan to use 9mm MDF for the front and side "walls" and cupboards. This will only cover the bottom frame and the vertical supports.

I plan to add a lip to the top frame made from whatevers going to be strongest. I will then add a metal brace on each corner, so 8 of them to add strength.

I'm not sure how I'm going to stick it all together yet. Not sure wether to use a wooden dowel or nails. If anyone has made a stand could shed some light on this.

On the bottom frame, would it be beneficial to add a piece of plywood so there is more area on the floor so there is less pressure? Without the plywood is 5000/.41= 12195 Pascals. Or with the plywood providing it is dead flat 5000/.935=5347 Pascals. Of course I'll add something to the top frame as well. Is there any benefit of MDF vs Plywood in this situation? Of course MDF will rot with water, but it is cheaper. Or is plywood less bendable?

Oh and I calculated the total cost at $132 so far.

Thanks in advance

Matt

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I looked at some other tank stands and it looks like I'm doing this wrong.

Instead of the top and bottom frames being on its front, it should be on its side?

I originally was thinking about doing it this way, but then you can only have 50x50 vertical supports.They don't seem that secure compared to a 100x100 vertical support.

Is there any downsides to doing it my way?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi

Thanks Si Sphinx, What did you use to hold your stand together? And how big is it?

I see it is pretty standard to have the top frame like Si's and have a flat base. Did you end up putting an MDF or Plywood "lid" on it? So there is an even distribution of weight.

And in regards to both stands, did either end up having a lip? I hear it will help save a tank in an earthquake.

Thanks again

Matt

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I see it is pretty standard to have the top frame like Si's and have a flat base. Did you end up putting an MDF or Plywood "lid" on it? So there is an even distribution of weight.

And in regards to both stands, did either end up having a lip? I hear it will help save a tank in an earthquake.

having two pieces of timber like that creates a beam which allows you to spread the legs out further. my legs are 500mm apart and the timber is 70x45 for the platform and 70x35 for the legs.

no lip, do you mean around the base of the tank?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

just turned it over, i did add the bracing at the ends after that pic. it is 800mm to the top of the particle board.

Oh ok thanks for that I was quite confused there :sml1:

having two pieces of timber like that creates a beam which allows you to spread the legs out further. my legs are 500mm apart and the timber is 70x45 for the platform and 70x35 for the legs.

no lip, do you mean around the base of the tank?

Yeah, apparently it stops it from slipping. Even though itd be hard to move a 500kg tank with a low centre of gravity, I believe a big one would quite easily break it.

And so I flip all of the pieces of wood on their sides, would I still be able to get away with only having 6 vertical braces or would I better off with 8? I think I would still use 100x100 vertical braces as its still just as safe if not safer. I would then add a block on the inside of the frame where the vertical braces meets the top frame so it connects them together more. I'm not sure if that makes sense and I'll get some drawing up soon.

Using the long members on edge rather than on the flat is stronger and a lip around the top has become very popular in this part of the woods since the shakes. We are none of us immune.

Hi Alan,

So what do most people use as a lip? I was thinking of attaching plywood to the top frame so it sits just a bit above where the tank will fit in.

Of course this makes the tank harder to move due to being have to be lifter over this lip. I had a dream about a stand with wheels... :facepalm:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Using the long members on edge rather than on the flat is stronger and a lip around the top has become very popular in this part of the woods since the shakes. We are none of us immune.

if those are 140mm pieces in Si's stand, they are rated (loaded dimension of 6m) as being able to span 1.4m as a window lintel for a house with a concrete tile roof, 1.7m for a longrun steel roof so you could likely be safe to park your car on Si's stand.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And so I flip all of the pieces of wood on their sides, would I still be able to get away with only having 6 vertical braces or would I better off with 8? I think I would still use 100x100 vertical braces as its still just as safe if not safer. I would then add a block on the inside of the frame where the vertical braces meets the top frame so it connects them together more. I'm not sure if that makes sense and I'll get some drawing up soon.

i have 5 verts, mine is 2.0m long and i used 70x45 timber so its longer, less verts and smaller timber.

With 100x50 on its flat I would go 4 as the tank is not going to point load on any of the horizontal framing, especially once you have a sheet of MDF/PLY/PB and poly on it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if those are 140mm pieces in Si's stand, they are rated (loaded dimension of 6m) as being able to span 1.4m as a window lintel for a house with a concrete tile roof, 1.7m for a longrun steel roof so you could likely be safe to park your car on Si's stand.

Yes it is very strong (maybe two cars strong) especially when I added the ply cladding. I could of easily gotten away without the center leg but oh well.

100_0081.jpg

It is all just screwed together. its 2m long, 900mm high and 650mm wide

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Si

Okay thanks for that. I see you only have a lip on 3 sides?

Haha it's a high stand. I needed a short one either wise I won't be able to reach the bottom :wink:

Thanks

Yea I have to stand on a small ladder to reach the bottom of my tank.

There is only a lip on three sides so I could slide the tank on from the back. the lip is really just for looks more than a structural thing. If an earthquake hit down here it would break it and slide right off if it was a decent quake. The lip really needs to be fixed on quite strong. I have seen pics of a tank that had split the lip open at the joins because of an earthquake.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi all :wave:

I've been looking at building a stand out of 100x100s and it would cost me about $150 all up. Wood would cost about $100 ($70 for the 100x100s + a sheet of MDF for walls ect.) and probably about $50 for screws and paint ect.

But I'm having trouble finding 150mm screws. Does anyone know where to find these?

Or is using liquid nails enough (I doubt it but worth an ask)? Or maybe liquid nails + a thick piece of dowel like Bishop used to make their tank stand? I'll get a picture of what I mean in a second. Link to the stand 3rd or 4th picture down I think?

http://www.fnzas.org.nz/fishroom/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=56567

Thanks

Matt

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, I was thinking of using two screws per 2 corner or 4 per 3 pieces of wood intersection

Ill get a picture of what I mean in a second.

@smidey, the tank is 170x55x58 but will only probably be filled 30-40cm/58cm

Yeah it was the coach screws at mega 10 that I saw, but if I use them in the same structure above its going to cost me $60 in screws.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...