Calurpa takes certain forms of phosphate out. It also introduces calurpins, which has a toxic effect on some animals. Calurpa is less than 0.04% phosphorous by weight. It takes a lot of calurpa to remove a little phosphate.
Skimmers do remove phosphate, it is their primary purpose. Not to mention all the other organics, like calerpins, turpines etc, which skimmers remove, which would otherwise end up causing trouble.
These have to be removed somehow. Without a skimmer, there is a LOT of maintenance involved.
Of course there are "band-aid" type temporary solutions which you can use to delay maintenance (like DSB's), but sooner or later they fail too.
Layton